Kentucky’s series record 4–0. Scores list Kentucky first.
| Date | Game | Result | Score | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sept 29, 1917 | Butler at Kentucky | W | 33–0 | — |
| Sept 30, 1916 | Butler at Kentucky | W | 39–3 | — |
| Oct 2, 1915 | Butler at Kentucky | W | 33–0 | — |
| Sept 27, 1913 | Butler at Kentucky | W | 21–7 | — |
Game results come from the Kentucky football season archive. Box scores are linked where a game-specific source was verified.